Want to try our resources? Sign up for our 14-Day Free Trial

Do assumptions do more harm than good?

29th November - 06th December 2024

Back to results

54505

Total votes

12892

5-11 votes

41613

11-16+ votes

To celebrate International Day of People with Disabilities on 3rd December, voters reflected on the assumptions that are often made about people with disabilities, and the potential issues these can cause. They also discussed the Government’s now inactive “Ask, Don’t Assume” campaign and its subsequent backlash, and heard testimonies from those with disabilities who have had assumptions made about them by others.

Primary 7-11, Secondary, 16+ & College voters were asked: “Do assumptions do more harm than good?”, while Primary 5-7 voters considered: “Should we be more careful about assumptions?”

54,505 young people in the UK have taken part in this vote.

Age 5-11 voter

I think assumptions can be quite harmful at times because they can offend others. This is because you are setting a limit on someone's abilities without knowing.

Age 11-16 voter

Assumptions aren't always helpful and can be limiting. Things like badges and the sunflower lanyards have been useful in reducing assumptions and subtly highlighting hidden disabilities.

Age 11-16 voter

Students felt that assumptions were good for self preservation and that they can change their assumptions when they learn more information.

Feedback from our impact partners

Thank you to National Deaf Children's Society, Scope and Disability Rights UK for responding to voters on this topic!

"The recent debate on whether assumptions do more harm than good, engaging over 54,000 young people across the UK, is both timely and significant. In recognition of International Day of Disabled People, students delved into the impact of assumptions on individuals with disabilities, discussing the government's 'Ask, Don't Assume' campaign and hearing firsthand accounts from those affected.

The overwhelming consensus—82% of voters believing that assumptions cause more harm than good—highlights a critical awareness among youth. Many students noted that assumptions can lead to limiting beliefs about a person's capabilities, particularly concerning Disabled people. They emphasised the importance of not presuming someone's abilities or needs, especially since many disabilities are not immediately visible.

At Disability Rights UK, we are heartened by the thoughtful engagement these young individuals demonstrate. Their recognition that assumptions can perpetuate stereotypes and create barriers aligns with our mission to promote equality and inclusion. By fostering a culture of inquiry, curiosity and empathy and encouraging people to ask rather than assume, we can dismantle prejudices and build a more inclusive society.

We commend VotesforSchools for facilitating this meaningful conversation and are inspired by the student's commitment to challenging assumptions. Their voices are instrumental in driving societal change, and we look forward to seeing the positive impact they will undoubtedly have in promoting understanding and respect for all individuals, regardless of ability.”

Disability Rights UK

  • 5-7-year olds were discussing the question, "Should we be more careful about assumptions?" and 90% said 'Yes'
  • Meanwhile, 7-11-year olds, Secondary, College and 16+ students discussed the question, "Do assumptions do more harm than good?" and 82% voted 'Yes'

  • Secondary students mostly argued that assumptions do more harm than good, with many arguing that we shouldn't assume someone with a disability isn't capable of achieving something.
  • Others stressed that some disabilities are invisible and so it's just as important to not assume a person doesn't need support or accessibility options.

  • Whilst most young people thought assumptions had mostly negative consequences, some did feel more positively about them
  • For example, some students said assuming rather than asking can be kinder and more polite
  • Others warned that if we make people worry too much about saying the right or wrong thing, it could prevent important conversations from taking place
results